The Risks in Licensing a Patent

Licensing a patent can be an effective strategy for monetising intellectual property, but it also involves various risks and threats. 

​

Legal Risks

 

Patent Invalidity : If the licensed patent is later found to be invalid (e.g., due to prior art or a challenge by a third party), the licensee may have grounds to terminate the agreement, and the licensor may lose licensing income.

Infringement Liability : Licensees might infringe on third-party patents during the use of the licensed patent, potentially leading to costly litigation. Some agreements try to indemnify the licensee against these risks, but this could still be a substantial cost to the licensor.

Enforcement and Litigation : If a third party infringes on the licensed patent, enforcing the patent is often costly and complex. Disputes may also arise if licensees or sublicenses do not adhere to the terms, forcing the licensor to litigate or negotiate.

​

Economic Risks

 

Revenue Dependence : Relying heavily on one or a few licensees can be risky, especially if market or financial conditions affect the licensee’s ability to continue payments.

Underpricing : Determining an appropriate royalty rate can be challenging. If the licensing terms are not competitive, it can result in undervaluing the patent and significant lost revenue.

Royalty Collection Issues : Monitoring and collecting royalties can be challenging, especially with multiple licensees. Self-reporting by licensees can lead to underreporting, whether intentional or unintentional.

Market Saturation : Granting too many licenses can saturate the market, reducing the technology's value and limiting future licensing opportunities.

​

Operational and Management Risks

 

Quality Control and Brand Dilution : If the licensee does not uphold quality standards, it can harm the licensor’s reputation. This is especially crucial in industries where brand integrity is directly tied to product quality.

Resource Constraints : Managing and overseeing a licensing program requires resources and expertise, especially when dealing with multiple licensees, international markets, and compliance with patent law across jurisdictions.

​

Strategic Risks

​

Loss of Competitive Advantage : Licensing a patent to competitors can erode the licensor’s competitive advantage. Competitors with access to patented technology may use it to build upon and even improve it, potentially capturing market share.

Exclusive Licensing Risks : In exclusive agreements, the licensor cannot license the technology to anyone else, limiting potential market reach and revenue. If the exclusive licensee fails to bring the product to market effectively, this can lead to wasted potential.

Loss of Control Over Innovation Direction : Licensing may result in a loss of control over the development and usage of the patented technology. Licensees may modify or adapt the technology in ways that diverge from the licensor’s vision or strategic goals.

​

Foreign Licensing and IP Risks

​

Jurisdictional Challenges : Different countries have unique IP laws, making enforcement of patent rights difficult or impractical. Licensors might find it hard to enforce contract terms or combat infringement in jurisdictions with weak IP laws.

Cross-Border Enforcement : Foreign licensees may attempt to circumvent patent laws or licensing agreements in less enforceable jurisdictions, leading to revenue loss.

Currency and Economic Instability : Licensing internationally introduces currency fluctuation risks, potentially reducing royalties when exchange rates change unfavorably or economies become unstable.

 

Technology and Market Risks

​

Obsolescence and Rapid Technological Change : If the technology becomes obsolete due to advancements or shifts in industry standards, the value of the patent diminishes, affecting the terms of current and future licenses.

Market Unpredictability : Changes in consumer demand or regulatory environments can impact the profitability of products or services that rely on the licensed patent, impacting both parties' revenues.

 

Relationship and Compliance Risks

​

Misalignment of Interests : Licensors and licensees might have different goals and expectations, which can lead to conflicts over usage, quality standards, or marketing strategies.

Compliance and Reporting : Monitoring a licensee’s compliance with usage and reporting requirements can be challenging. Misreporting or non-compliance can lead to disputes, financial losses, or termination of the agreement.

Termination and Transition Risks : If a license agreement is terminated, both parties might face risks related to transitioning out of the agreement, especially if products or services have been commercialized around the licensed technology.

​

Mitigation Strategies

​

To manage these risks, licensors and licensees can :

​

• Conduct thorough due diligence and market analysis before entering a licensing agreement.

• Include protective clauses in agreements, such as warranties, indemnification, quality standards, audit rights, and termination clauses.

• Regularly monitor and enforce compliance with the terms of the license.

• Seek legal and financial expertise to structure flexible yet secure agreements.

 

Summary

​

Licensing offers substantial potential for both parties, but understanding and managing these risks is essential to sustaining the agreement's long-term success.